link to Mitchell home pagewww.wmitchell.edu

Judicial history was made this fall at William Mitchell College of Law when a three-judge panel of the Minnesota Court of Appeals heard a mock argument, conferred, and decided a case and convened a Special Term to discuss and decide a calendar of motions before an audience of 120 attorneys, students, and legal professionals. The proceedings, usually done in closed chambers, were part of a symposium at William Mitchell celebrating the Court’s 25th anniversary on Nov. 6. The daylong event featured remarks from Minnesota Chief Justice Eric Magnuson ‘76 and Minnesota Court of Appeals Chief Judge Edward Toussaint Jr. Presenters included: Court of Appeals Judges Harriet Lansing and Bruce Willis (ret.); former Justice Sam Hanson ‘65, Briggs and Morgan; Marianne Short, Dorsey & Whitney; and David F. Herr ‘78, Maslon Edelman Borman & Brand.

A partial transcript of symposium, including the Court proceedings, will be published in Issue 4 of the William Mitchell Law Review and the entire transcript will be available on their Web site at: www.wmitchell.edu/lawreview/ in May 2009. If you would like a copy of the transcript before then, email lreview@wmitchell.edu.

 

Symposium schedule

November 6, 2008

8 – 8:30 am

Registration
and continental breakfast

8:30 – 9:30 am

Opening remarks

Minnesota Supreme Court Chief Justice Eric Magnuson

Minnesota Court of Appeals Chief Judge Edward Toussaint Jr.

9:30 – 10:45 am

Panel Discussion:
Impact of the Court of Appeals

Moderator: Marianne Short, former judge of the Court of Appeals; managing partner, Dorsey & Whitney, Minneapolis

Criminal law:Bradford Colbert, Minnesota Public Defender's Office, and

John B. Galus, assistant attorney general

Family Law: Cathy Gorlin, Best & Flanagan, Minneapolis

Civil Litigation: Dick Pemberton, Pemberton, Sorlie, Rufer, Kershner, Fergus Falls

Legal Services: Lawrence R. McDonough, Legal Aid Society of Minneapolis

10:45 – 11 am

Break

11 am – 12:45 pm

Arguing to, and Limitations of, an Error-Correcting Court
Sam Hanson, former associate justice, Minnesota Supreme Court; shaeholder, Briggs & Morgan, Minneapolis

Ten (or so) Things Practitioners Wish the Court Would Do Differently
David F. Herr, partner, Maslon Edelman Borman & Brand, Minneapolis

Ten (or so) Things the Court Wishes Practitioners Would Do Differently
Judge Bruce Willis, Minnesota Court of Appeals (retired)

12:45 – 2 pm

Lunch

Address: The Minnesota Court of Appeals: Twenty-five Years of Doing Minnesota Justice, Minnesota Court of Appeals Judge Harriet Lansing

2 – 3:15 pm

Mock Court of Appeals Argument and Conference

Argument of real Court of Appeals case (previously settled) and conference before a three-judge panel of Court members,

Attorney for appellants, Kay Nord Hunt, Lommen, Abdo, Cole, King & Stageberg, Minneapolis

Attorney for respondents, Richard Morgan, Bowman and Brooke, Minneapolis

Court members, Judge Terri J. Stoneburner, presiding, Judge Roger M. Klaphake, and Judge Matthew E. Johnson

3:15 – 3:30 pm

Break

3:30–4:15 pm

Return of Decision and Discussion of Arguments
Judges and faculty panel

4:15-5 pm

Special Term Conference

A different three-judge panel will confer on a calendar of actual special term motions and will decide them. This will provide an unprecedented glimpse into how the Court handles motions.

Court members, Judge Edward Toussaint Jr., presiding, Judge David Minge, Judge Randolph W. Peterson, and Judge Jill Flaskamp Halbrooks (substitute judge)

Questions

5 pm Adjourn

 

William Mitchell College of Law, founded in 1900, is an independent, private law school located in St. Paul, Minnesota. The college is known for cultivating practical wisdom and for creating an environment that welcomes both traditional and non-traditional law students. The largest law school in Minnesota, William Mitchell has produced many distinguished leaders at the bench and bar and in the business and civic arenas, among them the 15th Chief Justice of the United States, Warren E. Burger '31.